Call for revamp of dressage judging scale
An creature behaviourist with a doctorate inwards equine noesis proposes a revamped evidence-based scale for judging dressage, which he believes would move to a greater extent than accurate in addition to fairer than the electrical current FEI judging scale.
The managing director of the Australian Equine Behaviour Centre, Dr Andrew Mclean, said many people agreed that dressage was rife with subjectivity in addition to that in that place was a large grade of disenchantment with both participants in addition to audiences with the FEI judging scale, likewise known every bit the High German Training Scale. It was created inwards 1912 in addition to is based on a mixture of subjective in addition to objective elements.
McLean, presenting at the tenth International Equitation Science Conference inwards Denmark, said elements of a grooming scale should move objective in addition to straight observable. It should let judges to distinguish grooming successes in addition to errors inwards a systematic way, he said.
The primal objective of dressage was to develop through a standardised progression of grooming methods, a horse’s physique in addition to ability, he said. The aim was to attain a Equus caballus that was calm, supple, in addition to flexible, in addition to confident in addition to willing to perform to its amount potential.
Under FEI rules, dressage is judged on 8 elements – precision, rhythm, suppleness, contact, impulsion, straightness, collection in addition to submission.
McLean evaluated the High German Training Scales, taking into describe of piece of job concern human relationship diverse scientific viewpoints, including an appraisal of shaping (reinforcing successive incremental approximations of a target behaviour), identifying subjective every bit opposed to objective elements of each scale, in addition to highlighting subjective, ambiguous in addition to scientifically flawed terminology that interfered with the judging process.
McLean, who is senior vice-president of the International Society for Equitation Science (ISES), proposes enhancing the existing FEI grooming scale with the Principles of Learning Theory inwards Equitation, every bit outlined past times ISES, past times integrating an objective in addition to justifiable judging scale that volition let the analysis/marking of a horse’s trained responses.
A revised evidence-based scale volition let judging to piece of job to a greater extent than accurate in addition to fair, he suggests, in addition to has the potential to move used inwards all equestrian sports.
McLean believes that judging in addition to Equus caballus welfare should piece of job hand-in-hand in addition to that the proposed judging scale volition ameliorate the welfare of horses.
The role of a to a greater extent than horse-facing judging scale would ultimately ameliorate the longevity of equestrian sports, currently threatened past times the inconsistent role of potentially vague criteria for assessing performance, he said.
McLean holds a PhD inwards equine noesis in addition to learning, a Bachelor of Science inwards zoology, in addition to a Diploma of Education.
He has been an accredited riding bus for to a greater extent than than xxx years in addition to has written v books in addition to authored 35 peer-reviewed mag articles.
He has lectured at the University of Tasmania for xi years inwards creature behaviour, jail cellular telephone biology, genetics, anatomy, ecology in addition to Tasmanian fauna.
He has won the highest Australian Science award, the Eureka Prize for Science.
McLean developed in addition to manages the Australian Equine Behaviour Centre, the almost internationally recognised Equus caballus grooming in addition to deportment alteration middle inwards Australia.
Belum ada Komentar untuk "Call for revamp of dressage judging scale"
Posting Komentar